Pastor sues Kanye West, saying 'Donda' track ripped off sermon
Kanye West arrives at the Vanity Fair Oscar Party in Beverly Hills, Calif., on Feb. 9, 2020. West's latest release is “Donda.” (Photo by Evan Agostini/Invision/AP, File)
A Texas minister is suing Kanye West, saying the rapper, producer and entrepreneur used a recording of one of his sermons without permission in the song "Come to Life."
Dallas County, Texas, pastor David Paul Moten sued West, his label Universal Music Group UMG.AS, and its subsidiaries Def Jam Recordings and the West-founded G.O.O.D. Music on Tuesday in Dallas federal court. The copyright infringement lawsuit says at least two sections of "Come to Life" feature excerpts from Moten's sermon.
UMG and an attorney for Moten did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the lawsuit. West, who legally changed his name to Ye last year, could not immediately be reached for comment.
Moten claims samples from his sermon comprise over 20 per cent of "Come to Life," which appeared on West's hit album "Donda" last year. Named for West's late mother, "Donda" went to the top of the Billboard charts and was nominated for a Grammy award for album of the year.
Moten said in the lawsuit that West has shown an "alarming pattern" of "willfully and egregiously sampling sound recordings of others without consent."
West has previously settled lawsuits over samples of a Hungarian singer on the 2013 song "New Slaves," a child's prayer on the 2016 song "Ultralight Beam," and a theater work about Jamaican activist Marcus Garvey on "Freeee (Ghost Town Pt. 2)," a 2018 collaboration with rapper Kid Cudi.
(Reporting by Blake Brittain in Washington, D.C.Editing by David Bario and David Gregorio)
Shopping Trends
The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at CTV News. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop. Read about us.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Are there U.S. military bases and American troops in Canada?
The U.S. military has more than 165,000 troops deployed in over 170 countries and territories, including Canada.
'Everything is on the table': Joly won't rule out cutting off energy exports to U.S. in face of Trump tariff threat
Foreign Affairs Minister Melanie Joly is not ruling out any countermeasures when it comes to dealing with U.S. president-elect Donald Trump — his threat of significant tariffs on Canadian imports, in particular.
Royal treasures hidden since Second World War recovered from cathedral
Historical treasures hidden for decades have been uncovered in the crypts of a cathedral, with items including burial crowns and insignia belonging to Medieval European rulers.
Former PM Chretien says Liberal party must move back to 'radical centre'
As the Liberal party searches for a new leader, former prime minister Jean Chretien says it's time for the party to move back to the "radical centre" to help its electoral fortunes.
New Canadian joins the navy, fulfilling his father's dream
Onboard a warship with 250 personnel, if you take the time to listen, you’ll discover a sea of inspiring stories.
'Thankful for the rest of my life': Woman's final goodbye with father captured on video at Winnipeg airport
One woman is expressing her deepest gratitude to the Winnipeg Richardson International Airport after the staff helped her retrieve the security footage of her final moments with her father.
As Biden joins the former presidents club, here are some ideas for his retirement to-do list
U.S. President Joe Biden is about to have a lot more free time. He need look no further than past presidents for ideas on what to put on his retirement to-do list.
California man says two of his cats died after drinking raw milk recalled for bird flu
A California man whose two cats died after drinking raw milk recalled for bird flu risk says he meant to keep his beloved pets healthy, but his efforts tragically backfired.
Teen allegedly hit by vehicle while being pulled on GT Racer: OPP
Police in Orillia are investigating an incident that left a 14-year-old in the hospital after they were injured while being pulled on a GT Racer.
Canada
-
Are there U.S. military bases and American troops in Canada?
The U.S. military has more than 165,000 troops deployed in over 170 countries and territories, including Canada.
-
New Canadian joins the navy, fulfilling his father's dream
Onboard a warship with 250 personnel, if you take the time to listen, you’ll discover a sea of inspiring stories.
-
Delays, Trudeau resignation threaten Toronto-Quebec City high-frequency rail project
Canadians hoping plans for high-frequency rail between Toronto and Quebec City would move forward this year will instead see further delays — and the prospect of a federal election makes the timeline more uncertain than ever.
-
Teen allegedly hit by vehicle while being pulled on GT Racer: OPP
Police in Orillia are investigating an incident that left a 14-year-old in the hospital after they were injured while being pulled on a GT Racer.
-
Smiths Falls, Ont. firefighter recounts dramatic ice rescue
Fire officials in Smiths Falls are warning the public over the dangers of ice after a 14-year-old boy fell into freezing waters on Friday afternoon.
-
Lone sailor trapped in ice sparks concern in Southern Georgian Bay
A lone sailor living on a sailboat trapped in the Georgian Bay ice has sparked concern among Penetanguishene residents.
World
-
U.S. special counsel Jack Smith has resigned
U.S. Special counsel Jack Smith has resigned from the Justice Department effective Friday, according to a court filing.
-
Los Angeles wildfires death toll rises as crews fight heavy winds to save homes and landmarks
The death toll from the wildfires ravaging the Los Angeles area rose to 16 as crews battled to cut off the spreading blazes before potentially strong winds return that could push the flames toward some of the city's most famous landmarks.
-
No 'water system in the world' could have handled the L.A. fires. How the region could have minimized the damage
Even as flames in Southern California continued to carve a destructive path on Friday and fire officials sought to assess the damage and determine how the fires began, a larger question loomed: Could this level of devastation somehow have been minimized, or is this simply the new normal in an era of climate-related calamities?
-
As Biden joins the former presidents club, here are some ideas for his retirement to-do list
U.S. President Joe Biden is about to have a lot more free time. He need look no further than past presidents for ideas on what to put on his retirement to-do list.
-
Biden honors Pope Francis with the Presidential Medal of Freedom
President Joe Biden on Saturday honored Pope Francis with the Presidential Medal of Freedom with distinction, the highest civilian award given by the president, saying the pontiff was “a light of faith, hope, and love that shines brightly across the world.”
-
A bus accident on a highway in northeastern Germany leaves two dead
A bus accident on a highway in northeastern Germany on Saturday left two people dead and another four seriously injured, police said.
Politics
-
'Everything is on the table': Joly won't rule out cutting off energy exports to U.S. in face of Trump tariff threat
Foreign Affairs Minister Melanie Joly is not ruling out any countermeasures when it comes to dealing with U.S. president-elect Donald Trump — his threat of significant tariffs on Canadian imports, in particular.
-
Former PM Chretien says Liberal party must move back to 'radical centre'
As the Liberal party searches for a new leader, former prime minister Jean Chretien says it's time for the party to move back to the "radical centre" to help its electoral fortunes.
-
Former B.C. premier says she 'misspoke' when claiming she was never a Conservative
Former British Columbia premier Christy Clark, who is considering a run for federal Liberal leader, has backtracked on her claim this week that she'd never been a member of the Conservative party.
Health
-
California man says two of his cats died after drinking raw milk recalled for bird flu
A California man whose two cats died after drinking raw milk recalled for bird flu risk says he meant to keep his beloved pets healthy, but his efforts tragically backfired.
-
University of Guelph sees positive norovirus test as 190 report feeling ill
An Ontario public health official says they've detected norovirus among a group of 190 people reporting symptoms of gastroenteritis at the University of Guelph over the last week.
-
Toronto still trying to get students ‘back on track’ with vaccinations after COVID-19 pandemic
Toronto Public Health has begun sending out letters to Grade 11 students who are behind on their routine vaccinations, warning that they could face suspension if they do not comply.
Sci-Tech
-
Jeff Bezos’ Blue Origin set to launch its first orbital rocket — the powerful New Glenn
Nearly a quarter century after Jeff Bezos founded Blue Origin, the rocket company is poised for its most defining moment to date: sending a vehicle to orbit for the first time.
-
They built careers on TikTok. Now they’re bracing for a possible ban
On Friday, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments on TikTok’s legal challenge to the law, which the company claims violates its First Amendment rights and those of its 170 million American users
-
'Really unique': Ice core drilled by U of M scientist could unlock climate history
A Manitoba researcher was part of a historic research team that uncovered the oldest ice core ever retrieved.
Entertainment
-
With Conservatives promising to 'defund,' could the next election kill the CBC?
In late 2023, Heritage Minister Pascale St-Onge said it was time for the federal government to redefine what the CBC does and how it does it.
-
'A miracle.' James Woods posts on X that his house survived Los Angeles wildfires
Actor James Woods says his house in Pacific Palisades has survived the Los Angeles wildfires that had devastated much of his neighbourhood.
-
Mel Gibson latest celebrity to share loss of home due to wildfires
Mel Gibson's home in Malibu was destroyed by the Los Angeles wildfires while he was away recording a podcast with Joe Rogan in Austin, Texas, Gibson has revealed.
Business
-
opinionopinion Financial survival tips for the sandwich generation
The so-called 'sandwich generation' finds itself in a unique and challenging position as its members balance providing financial support for both aging parents and children, all while managing their own financial goals.
-
The implications for Canada if Trump goes through with his punishing Tariffs
A trillion dollars worth of Canadian goods and services are exported out of the country annually with a third of it going to the United States. One economist says if Trump imposes a 25 per cent tariff on those goods, it will be detrimental to the Canadian economy.
-
Rebel News loses bid to quash fines for violating election law on third-party ads
The Federal Court of Appeal has dismissed Rebel News Network's latest bid to quash $3,000 in fines levied against the right-wing media outlet by the commissioner of elections.
Lifestyle
-
Northern Ont. friends prepare for 450-km ski and snowshoe trek
Jean-Philippe Marineau and Patrice Beauparlant, lifelong friends who grew up in Hearst, Ont., are training for a 450-km trek from Fort Albany to Hearst, Ont.
-
Waterloo, Ont. woman's lucky break: How her lottery win will help kids with disabilities
A lucky lottery ticket will end up benefitting an Ontario centre that supports kids with disabilities and their families.
-
'One-of-a-kind' fire-breathing dragon sculpture takes over Winnipeg yard
A Winnipeg sculptor’s latest creation could also double as a house guard.
Sports
-
Canada to face U.S. for gold at U18 women's world hockey championship
Canada will play for gold at the under-18 women's world hockey championship in Finland after beating Czechia 4-2 in semifinal action Saturday.
-
Canadian tennis star Shapovalov sticking with aggressive style under new coach
Canadian tennis star Denis Shapovalov knows what pundits and fans think he needs to do to find success: put the ball in the court more often.
-
L.A. Rams head for Arizona and a crucial playoff game with their minds on their fire-ravaged hometown
The players and coaches tasked with separating football from real life are finding it difficult, but they are determined to meet the challenges on all fronts when they “host” the Minnesota Vikings at the Cardinals' State Farm Stadium on Monday night.
Autos
-
From AI assistants to holographic displays, automakers showcase in-cabin experiences at CES
Automakers pulled out all the stops to showcase their latest advances for in-vehicle experiences at CES, the Consumer Technology Association’s annual trade show of all things tech, in Las Vegas this week.
-
U.S. probing about 2.6 million Tesla vehicles over 'Actually Smart Summon' feature
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration said on Tuesday it has opened a probe into 2.6 million Tesla vehicles in the United States over reports of crashes involving a feature that allows users to move their cars remotely.
-
Waterloo Regional Police Service helps recover 20 stolen vehicles in Hamilton, Ont.
Waterloo Regional Police Services helped recover 20 stolen vehicles in Hamilton, Ont.
Local Spotlight
'I didn't want to go cold turkey:' Environment Canada's David Phillips on why he keeps working after retirement
When Environment Canada Senior Climatologist David Phillips retired this past September, he wasn’t quite ready to call it a career.
‘People are excited’: Portion of Rideau Canal Skateway opens for the first time this year
A section of the Rideau Canal Skateway has opened for the first time this winter.
Vancouver strip club's X account suspended over cheeky marquee message
The marquee at The Penthouse strip club in downtown Vancouver is known for its edgy comments on politics and pop culture.
'One-of-a-kind' fire-breathing dragon sculpture takes over Winnipeg yard
A Winnipeg sculptor’s latest creation could also double as a house guard.
'Really unique': Ice core drilled by U of M scientist could unlock climate history
A Manitoba researcher was part of a historic research team that uncovered the oldest ice core ever retrieved.
'Loving each other, building memories:' B.C. couple facing life-threatening illnesses cherishes every day
Hayley and Bill Atkinson’s love story begins that night he abruptly left in the middle of playing a card game with friends, and didn’t return for a long time.
Long live the King: N.B. tribute artist to honour Elvis' 90th birthday with special performance
Though it has been nearly five decades since Elvis' death, his music and influence continue to inspire fans around the world, including tribute artist Thane Dunn of Moncton, N.B.
4 generations on 1 lot: One family's creative response to B.C.'s housing crisis
A single lot in Delta, B.C., that used to be home to a single rancher built in the 80s is the site of four separate homes, housing four generations of the same family.
'Unacceptable': Removal of beaver dam in Manitoba community sends surge downstream
The removal of a beaver dam in a rural Manitoba community is having some unintended consequences, sending a small flood downstream, catching residents off-guard.
Vancouver
-
Mission RCMP issue public call out amid mailbox thefts
Police are requesting the public’s help with an investigation into a series of mailbox and mail thefts in Mission.
-
Youths wielding imitation firearms arrested in 2 separate incidents in Abbotsford, police say
Police in Abbotsford say they responded to two separate incidents involving young people threatening others with BB or airsoft guns.
-
Senior charged with robbing Vancouver luxury store has died, coroner confirms
The 66-year-old man accused of holding up a Holt Renfrew store in downtown Vancouver last month has died, the BC Coroners Service confirmed Saturday.
Toronto
-
Toronto still trying to get students ‘back on track’ with vaccinations after COVID-19 pandemic
Toronto Public Health has begun sending out letters to Grade 11 students who are behind on their routine vaccinations, warning that they could face suspension if they do not comply.
-
Former PM Chretien says Liberal party must move back to 'radical centre'
As the Liberal party searches for a new leader, former prime minister Jean Chretien says it's time for the party to move back to the "radical centre" to help its electoral fortunes.
-
Downtown Toronto stabbing sends 1 person to hospital
One person has been seriously injured in a stabbing in Moss Park, Toronto police say.
Calgary
-
'Good neighbours': Montana residents share thoughts on Trump's '51st state' threat
As U.S. president-elect Donald Trump threatens to annex Canada, some residents in Montana are sharing their thoughts on the idea of Canada becoming the “51st state.”
-
Winsport hosts nearly 200 girls for the EmpowerHer Sport summit
On Saturday WinSport hosted the fourth annual EmpowerHer Sport Summit to help women navigate the “unqualified aspects of sport.”
-
Alberta RCMP advising people to avoid travel Saturday due to poor driving conditions
Alberta RCMP are asking people to avoid travel Saturday due to poor driving conditions in areas across Central and Northern Alberta.
Ottawa
-
Here’s how it feels in Ottawa this Sunday
It feels like -18 with the wind chill this Sunday morning in the capital.
-
Ottawa police identify man, 58, found dead in Barrhaven
The Ottawa Police Service has identified a 58-year-old man who was found dead in the city's Barrhaven neighbourhood on Friday night.
-
Smiths Falls, Ont. firefighter recounts dramatic ice rescue
Fire officials in Smiths Falls are warning the public over the dangers of ice after a 14-year-old boy fell into freezing waters on Friday afternoon.
Montreal
-
Tough lesson: Thousands of 'unqualified' teachers in Quebec schools
Monique Henry has been teaching English in Quebec for the better part of two decades without official certification. As a so-called "unqualified" teacher, she has had to learn her profession the hard way.
-
CTV News Montreal at 6 p.m. for Saturday, Jan. 11, 2025
Watch CTV News Montreal at 6 p.m. for Saturday, Jan. 11, 2025 with anchor Matt Grillo.
-
'It's a great way to hasten an early death': Montreal emergency warming station closes as city says it's not cold enough to keep open
A city-run warming station that sheltered more than 1,000 people at a YMCA has closed with the city saying it's not cold enough outside to keep it open.
Edmonton
-
Repeat offenders behind upscale hillside encampment, expert says they're outliers
Edmonton police say a sophisticated encampment in the Fulton Creek area was the work of repeat offenders.
-
Hyman nets winner as Oilers rally to beat Blackhawks 4-3
Zach Hyman scored a tiebreaking power-play goal in the third period, and the Edmonton Oilers beat the Chicago Blackhawks 4-3 on Saturday night.
-
Alberta RCMP advising people to avoid travel Saturday due to poor driving conditions
Alberta RCMP are asking people to avoid travel Saturday due to poor driving conditions in areas across Central and Northern Alberta.
Atlantic
-
Children rescued from fire, RCMP Halifax investigating
Fire services rescued three children from a house fire in Lower Sackville, N.S., Saturday.
-
N.B. Scottish society still going strong after 200 years
The Fredericton Society of Saint Andrew is celebrating its 200th birthday this year.
-
Royal treasures hidden since Second World War recovered from cathedral
Historical treasures hidden for decades have been uncovered in the crypts of a cathedral, with items including burial crowns and insignia belonging to Medieval European rulers.
Winnipeg
-
'Thankful for the rest of my life': Woman's final goodbye with father captured on video at Winnipeg airport
One woman is expressing her deepest gratitude to the Winnipeg Richardson International Airport after the staff helped her retrieve the security footage of her final moments with her father.
-
Waverley West fire station officially commissioned
A temporary fire station in one of Winnipeg’s fastest-growing neighbourhoods received the ribbon-cutting treatment on Saturday
-
New stretch of the Nestaweya River Trail opens
Outdoor enthusiasts in Winnipeg have a few more kilometres of ice to skate, cycle and run on.
Regina
-
Regina woman charged in death of infant after lengthy investigation
A woman has been charged in the death of an infant following a lengthy investigation.
-
Sled dogs run through parts of Sask., offering guided tour rides for guests
If you have a liking for dogs and are looking for something fun to do this winter, Campbell’s Racing Sled Dogs is for you.
-
Sask. overdose numbers in 2024 drop, according to new report
After three years of the highest count of deaths due to overdoses in Saskatchewan’s history, the numbers have declined.
Kitchener
-
Local kidney donors to conquer three Guatemalan volcanoes to prove there are no limits after donation
Two living kidney donors, from Bright, Ont. and north of Elmira, Ont., are gearing up for an extraordinary adventure to show the world that donating an organ doesn't just save lives—it can open up new possibilities.
-
Pedestrian suffers serious injuries after getting struck by vehicle in Cambridge
A pedestrian is in hospital with serious injuries after being struck by a vehicle in Cambridge early Saturday morning.
-
U.S. special counsel Jack Smith has resigned
U.S. Special counsel Jack Smith has resigned from the Justice Department effective Friday, according to a court filing.
Saskatoon
-
'Everybody wins': Saskatoon SPCA garage sale makes room for fundraising
Garage sale season started a little early in Saskatoon this year. The SPCA held a garage sale Saturday to make use of some its more abundant gently used donations that might go unused.
-
These Sask. highways are restricted following multiple weather-related collisions
Saskatchewan RCMP are urging caution on the roads as they respond to multiple weather-related collisions and incidents across southeastern and southcentral Saskatchewan.
-
Sask. teen charged with animal cruelty after dog found dead
A teen boy from Deschambault Lake, Sask., has been charged with animal cruelty after a dog was found dead in the community.
Northern Ontario
-
Two charged with first-degree murder, arson in northern Ont.
A man and a woman from Blind River have been charged with first-degree murder and a third person has been charged with accessory to murder after the fact.
-
Northern Ont. friends prepare for 450-km ski and snowshoe trek
Jean-Philippe Marineau and Patrice Beauparlant, lifelong friends who grew up in Hearst, Ont., are training for a 450-km trek from Fort Albany to Hearst, Ont.
-
It's sick season. Here's how to protect yourself from norovirus, COVID-19, flu and RSV
While many of the germs that cause this misery can circulate throughout the year, scientists think that the winter surge of flu and cold activity may be because we spend more time indoors and the cold, dry air may weaken our defences.
London
-
Dundas Street and Waterloo Street intersection closure begins Monday
Beginning Monday, January 13 the intersection of Dundas and Waterloo will be closed for utility work.
-
London Knights win again, Cowan extends point streak to 58 games
The London Knights maintained top spot in the Ontario Hockey League (OHL) standings after a 6-4 win in Owen Sound on Saturday night.
-
On the Bright Side with Julie Atchison
To brighten your week with good news, CTV London Meteorologist Julie Atchison is showing us the sunny side of things.
Barrie
-
Lone sailor trapped in ice sparks concern in Southern Georgian Bay
A lone sailor living on a sailboat trapped in the Georgian Bay ice has sparked concern among Penetanguishene residents.
-
Teen allegedly hit by vehicle while being pulled on GT Racer: OPP
Police in Orillia are investigating an incident that left a 14-year-old in the hospital after they were injured while being pulled on a GT Racer.
-
Traffic light allegedly destroyed during crash, impaired driving charges laid
Police in Collingwood have arrested and charged a man after he was allegedly under the influence of alcohol when he crashed into a traffic light.
Windsor
-
St. Clair student takes home award in provincial video contest
Developmental service worker (DSW) students across the province marked “We Inspire” week this November, celebrating what about their future career excites them.
-
Spits bounce back with victory over the Flint Firebirds
The Windsor Spitfires met the Flint Firebirds on the ice once more on Saturday evening, hoping to rebound after a loss in London on Friday.
-
'That's amazing': Brentwood Dream Home Lottery awards prizes
The 33rd annual lottery, held by Brentwood Recovery Home, revealed the winners of all 21 grand prizes, which had a combined value of more than $1.2 million.
Vancouver Island
-
Former B.C. premier says she 'misspoke' when claiming she was never a Conservative
Former British Columbia premier Christy Clark, who is considering a run for federal Liberal leader, has backtracked on her claim this week that she'd never been a member of the Conservative party.
-
‘That’s what good neighbours do’: B.C. sending help to fight California wildfires
British Columbia is preparing to deploy B.C. wildfire crews to southern California.
-
West Kelowna fire chief says L.A. devastation a haunting reminder of B.C. blaze
The fire chief of a British Columbia community devastated by a fast-moving wildfire in 2023 says it's "haunting" to see similar circumstances playing out in Southern California.
Kelowna
-
West Kelowna fire chief says L.A. devastation a haunting reminder of B.C. blaze
The fire chief of a British Columbia community devastated by a fast-moving wildfire in 2023 says it's "haunting" to see similar circumstances playing out in Southern California.
-
1 hospitalized, residents displaced after Kelowna apartment fire
Firefighters knocked down a blaze on the third floor of a low-rise apartment building near downtown Kelowna Monday afternoon.
-
Lost skiers rescued off B.C. mountain
Search and rescue volunteers in B.C.’s Okanagan successfully reunited two skiers with their family Friday evening.
Lethbridge
-
'Good neighbours': Montana residents share thoughts on Trump's '51st state' threat
As U.S. president-elect Donald Trump threatens to annex Canada, some residents in Montana are sharing their thoughts on the idea of Canada becoming the “51st state.”
-
Man dies after falling into sink hole at Fernie Alpine Resort
An investigation is underway by Elk Valley RCMP after a man died Wednesday after falling into a sink hole at Fernie Alpine Resort.
-
One Alberta man gets jail, another community time for 2022 Coutts border protest
Two Alberta men have been sentenced for their roles in the illegal Coutts border blockade in 2022.
Sault Ste. Marie
-
Impaired drivers in northeastern Ontario keep police busy during the first weekend of 2025
A series of impaired driving incidents in northern Ontario last weekend kept Ontario Provincial Police busy.
-
Police appeal for witnesses, video footage in death investigation on St. Joseph Island
Provincial police are appealing for more information as they continue to investigate a "suspicious death" that happened this month on St. Joseph Island, near Sault Ste. Marie.
-
Toxic drugs circulating in northern Ontario
Canada’s largest First Nations police service, the Nishnawbe Aski Police Service (NAPS) issued a community safety alert as extremely toxic drugs are likely circulating in one of the Far North communities it serves.
N.L.
-
Heavy equipment used to bash into a Newfoundland bank for second time in a month
Police in eastern Newfoundland say that for the second time in less than a month thieves have used heavy equipment to smash into a bank and steal an ATM.
-
Yvonne Jones, longtime Liberal MP for Labrador, retiring from federal politics
Liberal MP Yvonne Jones speaks to reporters before a meeting of the Liberal women's caucus, on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, on Wednesday, Jan. 24, 2024. Jones announced this morning that she will not be running in the next federal election for her seat in Labrador. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Justin Tang
-
Quebec energy deal touted as new chapter for Newfoundland and Labrador heads for vote
A draft energy deal with Quebec heralded as a game-changer for indebted Newfoundland and Labrador is heading for a vote Thursday night at the legislature in St. John's, N.L.
