Flames successfully extinguished in Downtown Orillia fire, rebuilding challenges loom

Three days after flames lit up the early morning sky, erasing decades of history and changing the face of Orillia’s downtown, the fire is now officially out.

Tuesday’ fire was finally extinguished by 5 p.m. on Thursday. “We were able to uncover what was still smoldering in the building. We were able to extinguish that, and we cleared the fire out,” said Orillia Fire Chief Chris Ferry.

Mayor Don McIsaac extending his gratitude, “On behalf of Council, I would like to extend our deepest gratitude to the Orillia Fire Department for their tireless efforts in responding to this devastating event. Their bravery and dedication to protecting our community are truly commendable,” he said. “We also thank all of our neighboring communities who have provided their resources and support, as well as the OPP, the Salvation Army, Red Cross, and North Simcoe Victim Services, and all the residents and businesses who have reached out to offer assistance.”

With the fire officially out, the building is back in the hands of the owner and insurance companies, who are left to piece together the aftermath. Meanwhile, tired fire crews and city engineers are focused on securing the structure and assessing the vast damage.

Fire Chief Chris Ferry Orillia Fire Chief Chris Ferry. (CTV News/ Mike Arsalides)

“At this point, the building is deemed structurally unsafe. The roof is entirely collapsed. We have exposed the three walls that could also collapse. They have removed the most dangerous sections of the building,” said Greg Miller, Orillia’s Chief Building Official.

While power has been restored to the majority of the downtown area but the two neighboring buildings remain in the dark.

The building owner, Jeff Pitcher, is trying to help his tenants, many of whom have lost their businesses in the rubble. “Some of them didn’t have insurance, they don’t have a place to operate out of. I’ve offered space at my office for free for them until they get their feet back on the ground,” said Pitcher.

In an effort to support his tenants, Pitcher has launched an online campaign to raise funds. “The money will be primarily used to support the tenants through this time with income and expenses. Anything that’s left over at the end will be put towards a rebuilding campaign to hopefully build back a new historical landmark.”

Jeff Pitcher Orillia building owner Jeff Pitcher on Jan 24, 2025.. (CTV News/ Mike Lang)

When asked whether the city would help fund the rebuild, officials stated that, under the Municipal Act, their role is to work closely with partners to provide resources, guidance, and support to affected businesses and individuals.

As a result of work taking place on site, there will be no vehicle access to Peter Street South from Mississaga Street to Colborne Street until further notice.

Meanwhile, the man accused of starting the fire awaits his next court appearance, facing charges of arson and disregard for human life. One of the conditions of his release is that he cannot possess a lighter. These charges have not yet been tested in court.

Pitcher estimates demolition costs have totaled nearly $500,000, with insurance expected to cover only 60 percent of the rebuild. City officials say they’re working to reopen the impacted area section by section.

1 of 33